Thursday, January 22, 2004
Nation-building politicians
George W. Bush was very critical of Clinton's meddling foreign policy in 2000, and he said the following in the 2000 presidential debates...
"I don't think our troops ought to be used for what is called "nation-building." I think what we need to do is convince people who live in the lands they live to build the nations. Maybe I'm missing something here? I mean, to have kind of "Nation Building Corp" from America? Absolutely not."
That's a failed campaign promise.
But none of the current Democratic front runners, even the ones that are called “anti-war” by the major media, are proposing anything substantially different. All believe that Saddam Hussein needed to be disarmed. All support meddling in the Middle East and elsewhere. All support welfare for dictators (foreign aid).
• Wesley Clark says we shouldn’t have gone about attacking Iraq alone, not that we shouldn’t have gone. Key word: Coalition.
• Howard Dean agreed with Clark in that he thinks we shouldn’t have gone alone. But his largest disappointment was that there was no plan for “after the battle” – no real plan to nation-build. Key words: Prudent planning.
• John Kerry voted to give Bush the go-ahead, but says that didn’t really mean Bush should’ve gone. He was giving the president a bargaining chip, but expected the president to be more prudent, stall, and issue threats he never intended to carry out. Key word: Nuance.
Where’s a guy or gal to turn if they believe this war has,
• led to unbridled growth in government?
• removed President Bush from accountability on other issues. That loss of accountability has removed the last vestiges of restraint or opposition the GOP was willing to mount to government growth -- they're now outspending the Democrats and expanding entitlements?
• meant a nation-building exercise that has already cost us nearly $100 billion, and that's just the beginning?
• resulted in thousands of deaths, 500 of which have been to Americans?
• violated the Constitution and standards of Just War, ripping at the moral fabric of the country?
George W. Bush was very critical of Clinton's meddling foreign policy in 2000, and he said the following in the 2000 presidential debates...
"I don't think our troops ought to be used for what is called "nation-building." I think what we need to do is convince people who live in the lands they live to build the nations. Maybe I'm missing something here? I mean, to have kind of "Nation Building Corp" from America? Absolutely not."
That's a failed campaign promise.
But none of the current Democratic front runners, even the ones that are called “anti-war” by the major media, are proposing anything substantially different. All believe that Saddam Hussein needed to be disarmed. All support meddling in the Middle East and elsewhere. All support welfare for dictators (foreign aid).
• Wesley Clark says we shouldn’t have gone about attacking Iraq alone, not that we shouldn’t have gone. Key word: Coalition.
• Howard Dean agreed with Clark in that he thinks we shouldn’t have gone alone. But his largest disappointment was that there was no plan for “after the battle” – no real plan to nation-build. Key words: Prudent planning.
• John Kerry voted to give Bush the go-ahead, but says that didn’t really mean Bush should’ve gone. He was giving the president a bargaining chip, but expected the president to be more prudent, stall, and issue threats he never intended to carry out. Key word: Nuance.
Where’s a guy or gal to turn if they believe this war has,
• led to unbridled growth in government?
• removed President Bush from accountability on other issues. That loss of accountability has removed the last vestiges of restraint or opposition the GOP was willing to mount to government growth -- they're now outspending the Democrats and expanding entitlements?
• meant a nation-building exercise that has already cost us nearly $100 billion, and that's just the beginning?
• resulted in thousands of deaths, 500 of which have been to Americans?
• violated the Constitution and standards of Just War, ripping at the moral fabric of the country?
Comments:
Post a Comment
